Game Dev · · 6 min read
Edge of Space, Part Eight: Seven Humans
Edge of Space met its first real players, seven human testers over one week, and the game held up. What I did to get ready and what a bot can never tell you.
Forty bots and me#
For three months the only players in Edge of Space were forty AI commanders and whoever I happened to be logged in as. The bots earned their keep, they play by the same rules as everyone else and they will exploit anything exploitable with total commitment, but they have one blind spot that I could not design my way around.
Bots never get confused.
A bot does not sit there wondering why the research button is greyed out. It does not stare at a planet with nowhere left to build and quietly decide the game is over. It does not give up. Only people do that, and before I let any people in I wanted to find those moments myself.
Playing the game on paper.#
So I wrote a simulator. Not a clever one, it just replays the real economy formulas for seven days with a greedy player who always buys whatever pays for itself soonest, and I ran it at a few different speeds to see what came out.
It was humbling.
Nearly every upgrade in the game pays for itself in about an hour, which means the optimal strategy is simply to buy the thing with the fastest payback and keep doing that. Worse, the homeworld fills up completely in about twenty seven hours no matter how slow I make construction. In part two I told you BUILD_TIME_SPEED was the tempo of the entire game, and I meant it at the time. It turns out it is the tempo of any individual building, not the pacing of the game, and the thing actually setting the pace was the resource curve all along. Three posts later and the map still had a wrong arrow on it.
The more useful thing the simulator gave me was a list of the places a new player gets stuck. The first twelve hours are starved of crystal and nothing in the game mentions it. Solar plants quietly eat a third of your surface before you ever unlock fusion. And at around hour twenty seven the planet fills up, the game stops being about building and becomes about expanding and fighting, and it never says so out loud.
None of that needed rebalancing. All of it needed telling. Waiting orders now say what they are short of and roughly when you will have it. The crystal counter pulses when crystal is the thing holding you up. The first time a planet fills, a single card appears explaining the three ways forward. Small changes, and they are the whole difference between a puzzle and a wall.
Things I only found by actually playing.#
Some problems will not show up in a simulation because they are not about numbers at all.
I upgraded my headquarters to level eleven and was mildly surprised it let me, because the description said max ten. It meant ten queue slots, not ten levels. One sentence of text, fixed in a minute, and it had been wrong for weeks.
Then I queued five hundred cruisers, which filled the hangar nicely, and immediately realised I needed a single recycler. There was no way to cancel a batch once it was running. That was not a text fix, that was a missing feature, and it went in the same day. You can now cancel anything in progress and get the resources back, and any hulls that have already finished stay where they are.
That led into the thing that had been nagging me since the bots arrived. Storage filled up within a few hours at day two income. A level one shipyard held exactly one wing of fighters. Every extra shipyard level cost another field on a planet that was already short of space. So a shipyard now opens with five hundred berths, storage capacity went up across the board, and depots finally hold plasma as well as metal and crystal. Fuel had been the one resource in the game with no real tank to put it in.
The last of it was achievements, because I wanted something to chase that was bigger than one universe. There are ninety six of them, and they belong to you rather than to an account, so they outlive a reset and can only be earned once. Tiered ladders for the obvious milestones, a dozen secret ones for the odd things, and titles at the top of each ladder that show up next to your name in the rankings. The first time my own account logged in afterwards it unlocked eight of them on the spot, which is precisely what being a veteran should feel like.
Then seven people showed up.#
Seven testers, one week.
I will be honest about what I expected. I thought the server would fall over, or the opening hour would lose half of them, or somebody would find an exploit in an afternoon that forty bots had missed in three months.
None of that happened. It went well, genuinely and unexpectedly well.
The seven were my family, and some of my children's closest friends.
I should say why that matters more than it sounds. In part one I wrote about OGame, and about eventually getting my partner and the children playing it with me, and about the trouble we had because OGame did not much like several accounts coming from one address. We ended up going through Tor to get round it, which is a ridiculous amount of effort to go to so that a family can play a game together, and we did it anyway, and we had a wonderful time.
Twenty years later the same people logged into a game I had written, and this time the rules were mine.
I did not expect that to hit me the way it did. I have been testing this thing for three months against forty commanders who do not exist. Watching names I recognise appear in the rankings, next to the bots, doing the same things the bots do, was the moment the whole project stopped being a long exercise in systems design.
What I can tell you is what the server saw, because that part is mine. Seven accounts running alongside forty bots, and the thing I cared about most held up: the empire kept going while they were asleep. People logged in the next morning to raids that had already landed, queues that had finished without them and fleets that had come home. Nobody could reliably tell which of their neighbours were people. The bots were raided, traded with, and in at least one case befriended.
What a bot can never tell you#
The simulator found the walls. The people found the feelings.
That is the part I could not test on my own, and it is the part the whole thing rests on. Whether the small dread I have been chasing since part one, the one where you check your fleets at twenty to eight in the morning because somebody real might have decided your defences looked thin, actually happens when the person on the other end is a person.
It does.
Seven testers is a test and not a launch, and there is a long way to go yet. But it is the first time Edge of Space has been a multiplayer game in the sense that word actually means, and the surface, the miners and the lamps coming on at dusk finally had somebody watching who was not me.
You can play Edge of Space for yourself at eos.simontasker.co.uk.